Ask HN: Why All the Indonesian Spam?

22 points by al2o3cr a day ago

The "new" page with dead articles shown has about 5 submissions per page with Indonesian titles and spam contents usually containing a phone number.

Sometimes they're posted by brand-new accounts, sometimes it's "aged" accounts that have never posted before. For instance, this one created in 2021 has posted 12 times in the last 2 hours:

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=TheDarkLegend

(you'll need to have showdead turned on)

Is this the world's most misguided phishing attempt? AFAIK dead posts don't get picked up by any search engines etc...

mtmail a day ago

Goal is to get indexed by search engines or LLMs and then show up as first phone number for "$airline customer support" or such. It's been going on for a while, I keep flagging them when I see them in my timezone. I thought it was Turkish.

The old accounts is amazing though. Either somebody really playing the long game or easy guessable passwords?

treetalker 14 hours ago

I also flag these on sight.

And when I do, I mutter "mekka-lekka-high, mekka-heinie-ho" to myself.

jjgreen a day ago

As an aside, I'd always assumed that you only got so many "flags" per minute or whatever, but I've had a half-dozen where my flag killed it dead (which makes it all rather fun), so maybe I was mistaken?

  • defrost 14 hours ago

    Not all HN users are "flag equal", if you consistently flag spam then sooner or later a mod will notice this (as many flags get reviewed) and you'll get upsized to "super flagger" - unlimited flagging power with one flag == death.

    You then get more scrutiny, start "petty flagging" (flagging a fellow legit HN user out of spite because <insert no good reason>) and you'll be demoted to the rank and file.

    If you email HN and ask they'll often happily tell you if you've been tweaked in some manner or another.

    • jjgreen 14 hours ago

      Interesting, thanks.

slater a day ago

I was wondering the same